Fact-check: Only child syndrome is a myth

Author

Published on :
Share:

Author

child syndrome

Rather than attributing certain behaviours to being an only child, parents need to focus on fostering positive social interactions and setting appropriate boundaries.

Growing up as an only child, I often found myself at the centre of attention during family gatherings. While I cherished the moments spent with cousins, I couldn’t help but notice the subtle comments and raised eyebrows directed my way. “Spoiled,” they whispered, or “lonely without siblings,” they assumed. The remarks echoed the pervasive notion of ‘only child syndrome’ that has permeated our cultural discourse.

However, recent research suggests that this long-standing stereotype may not have any scientific backing. The earliest study on the subject can be traced back to the 1800s. Psychologists G Stanley Hall and E W Bohannon conducted studies that purported to identify negative behavioural traits associated with only children. Their work concluded that only children were spoiled, selfish, and maladjusted, leading to the popularisation of the term ‘only child syndrome’. 

Modern analysis, though, has revealed flaws in the study methodology and conclusions, discrediting the theory as largely unfounded. Research conducted over the past century has found little scientific evidence to support any of the earlier claims about only children. 

Psychologist Toni Falbo, an only child herself, conducted extensive research in this area, finding that only children were comparable in most respects to their counterparts with siblings. In many instances, only children excelled in intelligence, achievements and parent-child relationships.

On the other hand, studies examining brain development have found differences in specific brain regions between only children and those with siblings, potentially affecting behaviour traits like creativity and agreeableness. However, contrary to popular belief, researchers state that being an only child does not inherently predispose individuals to negative traits. 

Factors such as upbringing, social environment, and individual personality play a significant role in shaping a child’s character. Moreover, the modern landscape provides ample opportunities for only children to socialise and interact with peers, mitigating concerns about loneliness or social deficits.

Psychologists emphasise the importance of recognising each child’s individuality. Shyness or introversion, for example, are natural traits that can manifest regardless of sibling status. Rather than attributing certain behaviours to being an only child, parents need to focus on fostering positive social interactions and setting appropriate boundaries.

In conclusion, contemporary research largely discredits the concept of only child syndrome. It is a myth, constructed on flawed research and outdated beliefs. A supportive and nurturing environment, coupled with opportunities for socialisation, can help any child thrive, regardless of family size.

Read More : Why health fact-checking is still important

Author